Thursday, February 27, 2020

Old School New School










Tuesday, February 11, 2020

Another ungrading leap into the unknown

I teach a capstone course for senior psychology majors about empathy, and have done so for more than 10 years. I moved from open class discussions about primary source readings (terrible) to using jigsaws to include all students in discussions about the reading. Worked pretty well. But it was still a class that operated via obedience, and did not give students much or any freedom or choice. 

So today I went to class with the notes I have pasted below. There were a few raised eyebrows, a few nervous questions, but I could also see the wheels turning in many brains.

We'll see how it goes...


Capstone: Empathy blown up
 3 things I know are true
  1. Empathy can improve every part of our lives
  2. People do their best work when they care about what they are doing
  3. I don’t know what you care about
My offer to you is that you can work on something you care about as long as empathy is involved, and I will help you. This project can replace everything on the syllabus going forward.
My hope is that you produce something that means something to you and that you are proud of.
Still ungraded. If you create something meaningful and that you are proud of then that’s an A in my book. If you just want to pass the class, we can figure out something that is worth a C. No judgment. You are in charge of your workload and final grade.
You creating something meaningful to you is more important to me than you doing any specific reading or assignment. So you can throw away the syllabus, say goodbye to Perusall, forget about all those articles, read the Alda book if you want to. It’s really good.
You can work on your own or in groups
I have no guidelines for what the end result of this project is because I cannot foresee what you will want to do. I will brainstorm with you if you want me to.

What do you care about?
  • What will you do after graduation?
How can empathy help you succeed in that endeavor?
  • What worries you about the future?
How can empathy help you address those challenges?
  • What are your passions, hobbies?
How can empathy increase your pleasure?
 Some of MY ideas for projects:
  • Devise a plan to improve your own empathy over the next 10 weeks, carry it out, and see if it worked. Get ideas for how to improve your empathy from research (some are on syllabus)
  • Perform an ‘empathy audit’ for the job you intend to have, describing how empathy is required in that job and how you could be better at that job if you improved your empathy. I bet there are studies about empathy an any job you want to have
  • How is empathy related to climate change? Can empathy be used to get people to take climate change seriously and change their behavior? What do you find if you search for studies about empathy and climate change?
  • How are our devices impacting empathy? What can we do about it? Is there research about devices and/or social media and empathy?
  • How is empathy related to the upcoming Presidential election? Are there candidates that are low or high in empathy? Are there candidates that are using empathy in their messages? There’s a cool body of research called political psychology
  • Are you creative? Make something creative related to empathy.
  • Write a research proposal.
  • What was the paper/project/activity that you most enjoyed and/or got the most out of as a college student? What about it was so great? Can you do that again about empathy?
  • There are some interesting readings in the syllabus that we haven’t gotten to yet about religion, virtual reality, literature, trauma, therapy, prejudice, and politics. Read those for ideas?
But these are things that I care about. What do you care about?
I hope what you’ve learned as a psyc major is that the best ideas are backed up with evidence, and that intuition is a very poor substitute for that evidence.

What will help you produce something meaningful that you are proud of?
  • Accountability 
    • Activity journal
    • Periodic individual meetings with me
  • Revision
  • Input from multiple sources
  • Other?
If you don’t want to take on this project you can complete this course as laid out in the syllabus. We’ll figure out how to do that.

Let’s finish the project we are working on right now, Who needs to know. This can be the seed of an idea for your project. So bring that paper to class Thursday.
Next Tuesday I want to know what you want to do for the rest of the semester.